Oakes Irrigation Research
Site
Carrington Research Extension Center * North Dakota State University
P.O. Box 531, Oakes, ND 58474-0531, Voice: (701) 742-2189, FAX: (701)
742-2700, email: rgreenla@ndsuext.nodak.edu
CABBAGE HYBRID PERFORMANCE TRIAL, 1996
Richard G Greenland and Leonard Besemann
Cabbage grows well in the cool climate of North Dakota, but cabbage production is limited due to market uncertainty and lack of information on available hybrids. Data were collected to determine suitability of the hybrids for both the fresh and slaw markets.
Table 9. Yield data, overall quality and head shape of early (fresh market) cabbage.
Table 10. Cabbage head characteristics for early (fresh market) harvest.
Table 11. Late (slaw market) harvest data and cabbage head color.
Table 12. Cabbage head characteristics for the late (slaw market) harvest.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Soil: | Hecla sandy loam and Embden sandy loam; pH=6.9; 2.8% organic matter; soil-P was high; soil-K was medium; soil-S was very low. |
Previous crops: | 1995 - tomato and pepper; 1994 - pumpkin; 1993 - field corn. |
Seedbed preparation: | Disked on April 22. Multiweeded (field cultivated) three times on April 22, once to incorporate fertilizer and twice to incorporate herbicide. |
Planting: | Direct seeded on April 23 with a Stanhay vegetable planter. Seeds were spaced about 7 inches apart in 17-inch rows. Plants were later thinned to 15 inches apart (about 26,000 plants/acre). Seeds were placed about ½ to 3/4 inches deep into a flat, fine seedbed. |
Plots: | Main plots were 34 ft long by one row (17 inches) wide. Each main plot was divided into 2, 17 ft long sections. The study had 4 reps. |
Fertilizer: | On April 17, broadcast 14 lbs N/acre and 70 lbs P2O5/acre as 10-50-0, 16 lbs N/acre and 19 lbs S/acre as 21-0-0-24, and 94 lbs K20/acre as 0-0-60. Sprayed 35 lbs N/acre as 28-0-0 on April 22. Side dressed with 110 lbs N/acre as urea on July 8. |
Irrigation: | Surface drip irrigation as needed. |
Pest Control: | Weeds were controlled using Treflan and Devrinol (1 pt and 2 lb/acre applied preplant incorporated on April 22), Dacthal (8 lbs/acre on April 24), Lentagran (2 lbs/acre on June 7), and by hand weeding. Sevin (1.5 pts/acre on May 29) controlled flea beetles. Cabbage was sprayed with Javelin (1 lb/acre on July 15), with Asana (8 oz/acre on July 10, July 26, and Aug 2), and with DiPel (1 lb/acre on Aug 9) to control cabbage looper and cabbage worm. |
Harvest: | One section of each main plot was hand harvested when heads were firm and of marketable size (early harvest). The other section was harvested about two weeks later (late harvest). Cabbage head characteristics were measured on representative cabbage heads selected at each harvest from each plot. |
Yields were higher this year than in 1995. Some of the better fresh market hybrids were Columbia, Atlantis, Blue Pak, Fresco, Ramada and Gideon. Columbia, Fresco, Atlantis, Royal Vantage, Ramada and Grand Prize were the best for slaw cabbage. Super Red 80 (fresh market) and Regal Red (slaw market) were the best red hybrids. See Tables 9 to 12.
Return to top of cabbage hybrid performance trial
Table 9. Yield data, overall quality and head shape of early (fresh market) cabbage in the Oakes Irrigation Research Station 1996 cabbage hybrid performance trial.
Hybrid | Seed source1 | Days to harvest | Harvest spread2 | Heads per acre | Yield | Overall score | Head | |
shape3 | size | |||||||
----------- days ---------- | 1000s | tons/acre | 1 to 10 | 1 to 5 | lbs/head | |||
Green cabbage | ||||||||
Rocket | JS | 98.8 a4 | 12 | 23.1 a-d | 40.8 c-h | 5.2 fg | 3.0 g-k | 3.5 ghi |
Columbia | JS | 102.9 ab | 17 | 22.1 b-e | 39.9 d-h | 6.0 def | 3.2 d-i | 3.6 ghi |
King Cole | FM | 103.1 ab | 16 | 21.1 c-f | 39.0 e-i | 4.1 hi | 3.0 f-j | 3.7 fgh |
Titanic | FM | 105.8 bc | 21 | 20.2 d-g | 46.4 a-f | 3.6 i | 2.7 jk | 4.7 bc |
Columbia | PS | 106.2 bc | 20 | 25.9 abc | 49.1 a-d | 6.1 b-f | 4.8 a | 3.8 e-h |
Atlantis | PS | 110.8 cde | 25 | 22.1 b-e | 47.3 a-f | 6.0 def | 3.1 e-j | 4.3 b-e |
Gourmet | FM | 110.9 cde | 13 | 22.2 b-f | 48.9 a-e | 3.5 i | 2.5 k | 4.4 bcd |
Blue Pak | FM | 112.4 de | 17 | 21.6 b-f | 41.4 b-h | 6.2 b-e | 3.2 e-i | 3.9 d-g |
Fresco | BZ | 113.6 ef | 23 | 24.0 a-d | 50.3 abc | 6.3 b-e | 2.9 h-k | 4.2 c-f |
Ramada | SW | 117.7 fg | 21 | 21.1 c-f | 47.2 a-f | 7.3 a | 3.0 g-k | 4.5 bc |
Fortress | FM | 118.0 fg | 21 | 23.1 a-d | 35.8 ghi | 4.3 ghi | 3.2 e-j | 3.1 i |
Grand Prize | PS | 119.1 gh | 28 | 21.1 c-f | 50.8 ab | 5.8 ef | 2.9 ijk | 4.8 b |
Royal Vantage | SK | 120.6 gh | 24 | 27.9 a | 44.7 a-g | 6.0 def | 3.4 d-h | 3.2 hi |
Gideon | BZ | 123.7 hi | 19 | 24.1 a-d | 52.8 a | 7.1 ab | 3.5 c-g | 4.4 bcd |
Vantage Point | SK | 126.8 ij | 31 | 17.3 efg | 46.5 a-f | 6.9 a-d | 3.0 g-j | 5.4 a |
Storage #4 | JS | 129.8 j | 15 | 16.8 fg | 38.0 f-i | 7.0 abc | 3.6 cde | 4.6 bc |
Hinova | BZ | 133.75 | 13 | 15.45 | 43.65 | 7.55 | 3.15 | 5.75 |
Amtrak | BZ | Not harvested due to very late maturity | ||||||
Saratoga | BZ | Not harvested due to very late maturity | ||||||
Red cabbage | ||||||||
Regal Red | JS | 107.8 bcd | 20 | 24.0 a-d | 29.5 i | 3.9 hi | 3.7 cd | 2.5 j |
Azurro | BZ | 108.9 cde | 11 | 20.2 d-g | 19.2 j | 4.8 gh | 3.9 bc | 1.9 k |
Super Red 80 | JS | 110.1 cde | 20 | 26.4 ab | 32.4 hi | 6.0 c-f | 3.5 c-f | 2.5 j |
Autoro | BZ | 129.3 j | 17 | 15.9 g | 19.2 j | 6.3 b-e | 4.4 ab | 2.5 j |
C.V. (%) | 3 | 46 | 16 | 17 | 12 | 11 | 10 |
1See appendix A for source codes.
2Harvest spread is the number of days between first head ready to harvest until last head in plot ready to harvest.
3Head shape: 1 is very flat; 2 is flat; 3 is round; 4 is tall; 5 is very tall.
4Values in the same column followed by the same letter are not significantly different at the 0.05 level (no letters in column = no significant differences between values in that column).
5The hybrid 'Hinova' was not included in the statistical analysis because of large variability between plots caused by late and uneven maturity.
Return to top of cabbage hybrid performance trial
Table 10. Cabbage head characteristics for early (fresh market) harvest in the Oakes Irrigation Research Station 1996 cabbage hybrid performance trial.
Hybrid | Seed source1 | Diameter | Density2 | Color | Core | |||
polar | equator | inside3 | outside4 | length | width | |||
--------- inches --------- | 1 to 3 | --------- 1 to 9 --------- | ------- inches ------- | |||||
Green cabbage | ||||||||
Rocket | JS | 6.3 def 5 | 6.3 d-g | 1.7 fg | 1.6 e-h | 2.7 f | 3.4 d-g | 1.0 bcd |
Columbia | JS | 6.5 bcd | 6.2 d-g | 2.5 bcd | 1.7 d-h | 3.4 b | 3.3 c-f | 1.0 cde |
King Cole | FM | 6.8 abc | 6.5 bcd | 1.8 fg | 1.9 def | 3.1 cde | 4.1 hij | 1.2 gh |
Titanic | FM | 6.9 ab | 7.3 a | 1.7 g | 1.8 d-g | 2.8 ef | 3.9 g-j | 1.2 gh |
Columbia | PS | 6.9 ab | 6.3 d-g | 2.8 abc | 1.3 hi | 3.0 de | 3.6 e-h | 1.1 def |
Atlantis | PS | 6.4 cde | 6.4 cde | 2.6 a-d | 1.5 f-h | 3.1 b-e | 2.7 a | 1.0 a-d |
Gourmet | FM | 6.5 bcd | 7.0 ab | 1.6 g | 1.6 e-i | 3.1 b-e | 4.2 ij | 1.0 b-e |
Blue Pak | FM | 6.5 bcd | 6.1 efg | 2.7 abc | 1.5 ghi | 3.2 bcd | 2.9 a-d | 1.0 bcd |
Fresco | BZ | 6.4 cd | 6.4 c-f | 2.5 cd | 1.6 d-h | 3.0 de | 3.2 b-e | 1.0 de |
Ramada | SW | 6.2 d-g | 6.3 d-g | 3.0 a | 1.9 d-g | 3.1 cde | 2.7 ab | 1.3 hi |
Fortress | FM | 6.0 fgh | 6.0 efg | 1.8 efg | 2.0 de | 3.0 def | 3.6 e-i | 1.0 bcd |
Grand Prize | PS | 6.6 bcd | 6.8 abc | 2.2 de | 1.9 def | 3.4 bc | 3.8 f-j | 1.2 fg |
Royal Vantage | SK | 6.3 def | 6.0 fg | 2.3 cd | 1.7 d-g | 3.1 b-e | 2.8 abc | 0.9 ab |
Gideon | BZ | 6.5 bcd | 5.9 g | 3.0 a | 2.1 cd | 3.1 b-e | 3.2 a-e | 1.2 fgh |
Vantage Point | SK | 7.1 a | 7.1 a | 2.8 abc | 1.1 i | 3.0 def | 4.2 j | 1.1 efg |
Storage #4 | JS | 6.6 bcd | 6.0 efg | 3.0 a | 2.4 c | 3.0 def | 3.6 e-i | 1.3 i |
Hinova | BZ | 6.86 | 6.66 | 3.06 | 2.56 | 3.06 | 3.06 | 1.16 |
Red cabbage | ||||||||
Regal Red | JS | 6.0 e-h | 5.2 hi | 1.5 g | 7.4 ab | 7.0 a | 3.3 c-f | 0.9 a |
Azurro | BZ | 5.6 h | 4.8 ij | 2.2 def | 7.6 a | 7.1 a | 2.9 a-d | 0.9 abc |
Super Red 80 | JS | 5.8 gh | 5.3 h | 2.9 ab | 7.0 b | 7.0 a | 2.6 a | 1.0 a-d |
Autoro | BZ | 6.4 cd | 4.7 j | 3.0 a | 7.5 a | 7.2 a | 3.0 a-d | 1.1 d-g |
C.V. (%) | 5 | 5 | 13 | 10 | 6 | 11 | 8 |
1See appendix A for source codes.
2Visual estimate of head density. The higher the number the more dense the head.
3Inside color: 1 is whitish green; 2 is yellow green; 3 is light green; 7 is medium purple; 8 is dark purple.
4Outside color: 2 to 4 is light to dark green; 5 - blue green; 6 - red green; 7 - purple green; 8 - purple.
5Values in the same column followed by the same letter are not significantly different at the 0.05 level.
6The hybrid 'Hinova' was not included in the statistical analysis because of large variability between plots caused by late and uneven maturity.
Return to top of cabbage hybrid performance trial
Table 11. Late (slaw market) harvest data and cabbage head color for the Oakes Irrigation Research Station 1996 cabbage hybrid performance trial.
Hybrid | Seed source1 | Days to harvest2 | Heads per acre | Yield | Overall score | Head color3 | |
outside | inside | ||||||
1000s/acre | tons/acre | 1 to 10 | ----------- 1 to 9 ----------- | ||||
Green cabbage | |||||||
Rocket | JS | 114 (4.5) | 18.7 e | 42.2 gh | 5.8 d-g | 3.0 d | 1.3 f |
King Cole | FM | 115 (4.2) | 20.7 de | 61.5 b-e | 4.8 fg | 3.3 bc | 2.0 cde |
Columbia | PS | 120 (5.5) | 23.1 cde | 61.1 b-e | 7.0 a-d | 3.1 cd | 1.3 f |
Columbia | JS | 122 (6.5) | 23.1 cde | 58.0 cde | 7.1 a-d | 3.0 d | 1.4 ef |
Titanic | FM | 122 (8.6) | 21.6 de | 71.4 ab | 5.3 efg | 3.0 d | 2.0 cde |
Gourmet | FM | 124 (2.0) | 21.8 cde | 68.1 abc | 4.4 g | 3.0 d | 1.5 def |
Blue Pak | FM | 125 (0.0) | 23.1 cde | 53.2 d-g | 6.3 b-e | 3.0 d | 1.8 def |
Fresco | BZ | 127 (4.0) | 26.4 abc | 78.1 a | 7.4 abc | 3.0 d | 1.4 ef |
Atlantis | PS | 127 (4.0) | 21.6 de | 65.0 bcd | 7.3 abc | 3.4 b | 1.5 def |
Royal Vantage | SK | 128 (6.0) | 26.4 abc | 65.1 bcd | 7.3 abc | 3.0 d | 1.4 ef |
Grand Prize | PS | 134 (6.6) | 23.0 cde | 67.2 abc | 6.1 c-f | 3.0 d | 2.1 cd |
Fortress | FM | 135 (3.0) | 19.2 e | 51.2 e-h | 6.0 c-f | 3.1 cd | 1.6 def |
Ramada | SW | 138 (3.0) | 25.0 a-d | 78.9 a | 7.4 abc | 3.0 d | 2.0 cde |
Gideon | BZ | 147 (12.8) | 18.74 | 59.04 | 7.9 a | 3.2 bcd | 3.0 b |
Vantage Point | SK | 149 (16.0) | 21.64 | 57.04 | 8.2 a | 2.9 d | 1.2 f |
Storage #4 | JS | 152 (9.2) | 19.24 | 48.24 | 7.7 ab | 3.0 d | 2.7 bc |
Hinova | BZ | 156 (3.7) | 21.14 | 56.34 | 7.7 ab | 3.2 bcd | 2.7 bc |
Amtrak | BZ | Not harvested due to very late maturity | |||||
Saratoga | JS | Not harvested due to very late maturity | |||||
Red cabbage | |||||||
Azurro | BZ | 125 (0.0) | 23.1 cde | 39.0 h | 4.9 efg | 7.0 a | 7.9 a |
Super Red 80 | JS | 126 (5.0) | 29.3 a | 44.6 fgh | 6.8 a-d | 7.0 a | 7.4 a |
Regal Red | JS | 127 (4.0) | 28.8 ab | 55.8 c-f | 6.1 c-f | 7.0 a | 7.6 a |
Autoro | BZ | 153 (0.5) | 24.5 bcd | 43.8 fgh | 7.4 abc | 7.0 a | 7.5 a |
LSD (0.05) | 8.2 | * | * | * | * | * | |
C.V. (%) | 4 | 14 | 14 | 15 | 4 | 17 |
*Values in the same column followed by the same letter are not significantly different at the 0.05 level.
1See appendix A for source codes.
2Number in parenthesis is the standard deviation of days to harvest. The higher the number, the more variable the harvest date.
3Head color:outside - 1=yellow green, 2 to 4=light to dark green, 5=bluish green, 6=reddish green, 7=purple green, 8=purple, 9=red.inside - 1=whitish green, 2=yellow green, 3 to 5=light to dark green, 6 to 8=light to dark purple, 9=red.
4Yield and heads per acre reduced due to some plots not maturing on time.
Return to top of cabbage hybrid performance trial
Table 12. Cabbage head characteristics for the late (slaw market) harvest in the Oakes Irrigation Research Station 1996 cabbage hybrid performance trial.
Hybrid | Seed source1 | Shape2 | Density3 | Head diameter | Core | ||
polar | equatorial | length | width | ||||
1 to 4 | 1 to 3 | ----------- inches ----------- | ---------- inches -------- | ||||
Green cabbage | |||||||
Rocket | JS | 3.0 cde4 | 3.0 a | 7.2 a-e | 7.5 a-d | 4.4 hi | 1.1 a-d |
King Cole | FM | 3.0 cde | 2.0 cd | 7.6 ab | 7.7 abc | 4.5 i | 1.2 d-g |
Columbia | PS | 3.5 abc | 2.8 ab | 7.6 ab | 7.3 a-f | 3.7 d-g | 1.2 def |
Columbia | JS | 3.0 cde | 3.0 a | 6.9 b-f | 7.0 def | 3.6 c-f | 0.9 ab |
Titanic | FM | 2.9 c-f | 2.0 cd | 7.3 a-d | 7.6 a-d | 4.3 ghi | 1.3 efg |
Gourmet | FM | 3.0 cde | 1.6 d | 7.2 a-e | 7.6 a-d | 4.4 hi | 1.1 b-f |
Blue Pak | FM | 3.3 bcd | 2.5 abc | 7.0 a-f | 6.8 ef | 3.1 abc | 1.2 d-g |
Fresco | BZ | 3.0 cde | 2.5 abc | 7.7 a | 7.7 abc | 3.9 e-i | 1.1 a-e |
Atlantis | PS | 2.5 ef | 2.9 ab | 7.0 a-f | 7.4 a-e | 3.5 c-f | 1.2 c-f |
Royal Vantage | SK | 3.0 cde | 2.6 abc | 7.1 a-e | 7.0 c-f | 3.3 bcd | 1.1 a-e |
Grand Prize | PS | 2.8 def | 2.3 bcd | 7.4 abc | 7.9 a | 3.5 c-f | 1.3 fg |
Fortress | FM | 2.3 f | 2.5 abc | 6.6 def | 7.3 a-f | 4.1 f-i | 1.0 ab |
Ramada | SW | 2.8 def | 3.0 a | 7.4 abc | 7.7 ab | 3.3 b-e | 1.4 g |
Gideon | BZ | 3.0 cde | 3.0 a | 7.4 abc | 7.1 b-f | 3.5 c-f | 1.2 d-g |
Vantage Point | SK | 3.1 b-e | 3.0 a | 7.2 a-e | 7.0 c-f | 4.3 ghi | 1.1 a-f |
Storage #4 | JS | 3.0 cde | 3.0 a | 7.2 a-e | 6.9 def | 3.8 d-h | 1.4 g |
Hinova | BZ | 2.6 def | 3.0 a | 7.1 a-f | 7.3 a-f | 2.5 a | 1.1 b-f |
Red cabbage | |||||||
Azurro | BZ | 3.8 ab | 2.9 ab | 6.5 ef | 6.0 g | 3.5 c-f | 0.9 a |
Super Red 80 | JS | 3.5 abc | 2.9 ab | 6.3 f | 5.8 g | 2.5 a | 0.9 a |
Regal Red | JS | 3.3 bcd | 2.6 abc | 6.9 b-f | 6.7 f | 4.0 f-i | 1.0 abc |
Autoro | BZ | 4.1 a | 3.0 a | 6.7 c-f | 5.5 g | 2.9 ab | 1.1 a-e |
C.V. (%) | 15 | 17 | 7 | 6 | 12 | 13 |
1See appendix A for source codes.
2Head shape - 1 is very flat; 2 is flat; 3 is round; 4 is tall.
3Head density - 1 to 3; 1 is loose and 3 is solid.
4Values in the same column followed by the same letter are not significantly different at the 0.05 level.
Return to top of cabbage hybrid performance trial
Go to Oakes Irrigation Research Site Variety Performance Trials
Go to Oakes Irrigation Research Site 1996 annual report