NDSU Extension - Mercer County


| Share

The Plow and Cow Are Strange Companions

beef cattle, cow-calf, cattle

Submitted by Craig Askim, Extension Agent, Agriculture and Natural Resources

The world of beef cattle, at least for some is good and so are profits. The cow-calf enterprise is making money for those who are in the upper 40 percent of gross margins minus direct and overhead expenses.

What is nice is that the cow-calf enterprise for those upper 40 percent of producers is contributing in a positive manner to labor and management. Cattle numbers, when return to labor and management is positive, will expand. However, the cow-calf business seems to be in a "wait and see" mode with many conflicting thoughts. Given the positive position for those producers who are financially successful, the cow-calf business should expand.

In the bigger picture, competition for available land resources is high. Competing crops with excellent projected returns beg the question: Why run cattle? Interestingly, in today's world, the question is twofold.

Were the cows profitable? If so, how profitable were they? Both of these questions need to be answered because competing crop enterprises offer some great opportunities for producers. Even if the landowner does not want to raise crops, leasing or cash rent opportunities may become very attractive to a cattle producer. From 2011 back through 2008, cattle producers who were enrolled in the North Dakota Farm Management program have had positive net returns over direct and overhead expenses.

The net return values were $182 in 2011, $111 in 2010, minus $13 in 2009, $12 in 2008. For 2012, it will be interesting to see what these numbers are, but one would speculate that the industry had positive net returns.

Are these high enough to keep producers in business? Yes, but let's look at those producers who were at the upper end of net the returns. This group of producers was in the black every year from 2008 through 2011.

The actual net returns over direct and overhead expenses for the upper 40 percent were a positive $299 per cow in 2011, $188 in 2010, $52 in 2009, $100 in 2008. The long and short of it is that this group of cattle producers had an average net return of $137.50 per year per cow.

This may seem like a lot of money, but producers still are asking if profit levels are high enough to offset the lost opportunity to do something that may have made more money on the same land. This is a tough question and one that even those producers that are successful financially in the cattle business eventually must address.

As noted earlier, there are two questions. The first: Were the cows profitable?

The answer is yes for the upper 40 percent of producers. How profitable were the cows was the second question. The answer is known for this set of producers, but there are red flags waving. These producers seem to understand that high income and low costs are critical.

However, the returns still need to compete on a per-acre basis with other agricultural enterprises. The plow is an instrument of change that can be positive or negative, but an instrument of change either way.

Source:  Kris Ringwall, (701) 483-2348, ext. 103, kris.ringwall@ndsu.edu

Creative Commons License
Feel free to use and share this content, but please do so under the conditions of our Creative Commons license and our Rules for Use. Thanks.